...Ok, The command to "Keep silence", when taken in context, means "in the formation of doctrine", as 1 Cor 14 is entirely about formation of doctrine based on Spiritual Outpouring. To take that verse and apply it to audible speech is not rightly dividing the Word.
So, ask away, that's not what the verse is talking about, but if you have a doctrinal question, best to go through your Husband
I noticed that in the FFF I have to argue just a part of my side in a way that's not really as balanced as I am just to get the point across... I hope that statement makes sense. - Mr. Penguin
...Ok, The command to "Keep silence", when taken in context, means "in the formation of doctrine", as 1 Cor 14 is entirely about formation of doctrine based on Spiritual Outpouring. To take that verse and apply it to audible speech is not rightly dividing the Word.
So, ask away, that's not what the verse is talking about, but if you have a doctrinal question, best to go through your Husband
oh. because I get the idea that men in church want us to "shut up" because godly women are quiet and meek (meaning, no questions)
...Ok, The command to "Keep silence", when taken in context, means "in the formation of doctrine", as 1 Cor 14 is entirely about formation of doctrine based on Spiritual Outpouring. To take that verse and apply it to audible speech is not rightly dividing the Word.
So, ask away, that's not what the verse is talking about, but if you have a doctrinal question, best to go through your Husband
Were in fairland did you get that from?
__________________
Quote:
Barack Obama was voted in by guilted whites and brainwashed blacks. Erik Rush
I noticed that in the FFF I have to argue just a part of my side in a way that's not really as balanced as I am just to get the point across... I hope that statement makes sense. - Mr. Penguin
in the church when a man is candidating, and invites the congregation to ask him questions?
is this "violating" scripture?
the scripture says let them keep silent "for it is commanded"....
but now it is commanded to ask questions. so, how is that violating anything?
I have studied this for a long time. There is an article out there called "Women keep Silent in the churches" in the book "Biblical Manhood and Womanhood" and the conclusion is that it is referring to the time when the Elders of a church are testing prophecies. in I Cor it says "When a woman prays or prophecies" and it tacitly thereby approves of both.
Location: the problem with Christianity isn't easy believism the problem with Christianity is easy prayerism
Posts: 16,862
Quote:
Originally Posted by tranquilpenguin
Great question....
....um....
...Ok, The command to "Keep silence", when taken in context, means "in the formation of doctrine", as 1 Cor 14 is entirely about formation of doctrine based on Spiritual Outpouring. To take that verse and apply it to audible speech is not rightly dividing the Word.
So, ask away, that's not what the verse is talking about, but if you have a doctrinal question, best to go through your Husband
and if hubby says it is ok to ask any type of question is that violating that command?
I have studied this for a long time. There is an article out there called "Women keep Silent in the churches" in the book "Biblical Manhood and Womanhood" and the conclusion is that it is referring to the time when the Elders of a church are testing prophecies. in I Cor it says "When a woman prays or prophecies" and it tacitly thereby approves of both.
So, no, she is not in violation.
. . . but prophecies have ceased. . .haven't they?
__________________
2 John 1:7 For many deceivers are entered into the world, who confess not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh. This is a deceiver and an antichrist.
I have studied this for a long time. There is an article out there called "Women keep Silent in the churches" in the book "Biblical Manhood and Womanhood" and the conclusion is that it is referring to the time when the Elders of a church are testing prophecies. in I Cor it says "When a woman prays or prophecies" and it tacitly thereby approves of both.
So, no, she is not in violation.
Which is my EXACT point.
They are to sing and participate, but not preach or form doctine.
Quote:
Originally Posted by grannylo
and if hubby says it is ok to ask any type of question is that violating that command?
Sounds like you asked him :P
I do think that he should ask the question publicly if he doesn't know rather that you, though.
Of course I don't think he should accept the pastors answer, but rather ask all the men in the church then decide ;D
I noticed that in the FFF I have to argue just a part of my side in a way that's not really as balanced as I am just to get the point across... I hope that statement makes sense. - Mr. Penguin
The views and opinions expressed on this web site are not necessarily those of the Fighting Fundamental Forums management. This is an open and unmoderated forum. The content of each post is the sole responsibility of the poster. Participants are expected to follow the simple rules of the forum. Within these wide parameters various views are welcome to be expressed freely.
The college names used on the FundamentalForums.com web site are trademarks of their respective schools. The forums are not officially sanctioned by any of the institutions represented.
Should the women keep silent
Linear Mode
